|
Amy
Syracuse
Dr. Morrill
History
4000-A01
July 1, 2008
Final Paper
This writer
contends that the dropping of the atomic bomb was needed in order to end
World War II, and defeat the Imperialist Japanese into unconditional
surrender. Due to the brutality throughout the entire war and the
unwillingness of the Japanese to abide by the Potsdam Declaration, there was
not any other option. Without the usage of these nuclear weapons, there
could have been half a million American casualties as well as all the lives
of the Japanese soldiers and civilians if the war continued. The cruelty is
proven from the war crimes committed by the Japanese. Not only were they
acting in these ways to American soldiers, but to any body they felt like,
including young women.
On December 7,
1941, the Japanese bombed Pearl Harbor in a surprise attack on the United
States, crumbling the navy fleet. The attack was without warning and the
Japanese were showing no mercy, destroying everything they could. Over two
thousand Americans died that day for no reason. The Japanese were allies to
the Germans and brought the United States into World War II. Before that
day dreadful day happened, President Roosevelt already had a project, known
as the Manhattan Project, which was researching and developing atomic
weapons.
Historiography
The use of
dropping atomic bombs on the two cities in Japan became, and still is one of
the most controversial topics among historians. Many of the arguments cannot
be resolved, because there is a lack of evidence that could help ones debate
against the droppings. However, with the decision to drop the bombs being
more complex, it brings along disagreement. In the book prompt & utter
destruction: Truman and the Use of Atomic Bombs Against Japan, J. Samuel
Walker discusses the issues that were occurring during World War II and
Walker’s idea that “if Truman had in fact faced a choice between authorizing
the bomb and ordering an invasion that would have cost hundreds of thousands
of American lives, the decision to use the bomb would have been obvious.”[1]
Ronald Takaki in
his book, Hiroshima: Why America Dropped the Atomic Bomb, attempts to
question the answer given to why the bombs were dropped; that it saved half
a million American lives. Takaki makes some good points, but takes them to
a whole new level making him look biased, for example, using the reasoning
that Truman was just trying to make up for a bullied childhood. Takaki
states, “Moreover, Truman had a secret, and, in time, he would show Stalin
how ‘big’ he, Truman, was.”[2]
In her book, The Manhattan Project and The Atomic Bomb:In American
History, Dorren Gonzales has the same views as most historians. How
thousands of young American soldiers were dying, and millions more were
perishing around the world. With Japan not willing to surrender on
America’s terms, there was no other choice except to drop the bombs, and
save American and Japanese lives.
There are
questions that will go forever unanswered in historian’s debate among
Truman’s ultimate decision. Whether a person thinks it was morally or
strategically wrong, there forever will be and have always has been somebody
on the other side with a difference in opinion.
From the Creation to the
Usage
For many years
physicists and the army worked together to create the ultimate weapon and to
do so before Hitler and Nazi Germany and it all started with an idea. Leo
Szilard, a Hungarian born physicist, thought that splitting an atom could
potentially release enormous amounts of energy. The splitting of one atom
would result in giving off particles that would split two other atoms, and
so on. He thought that if billions of atoms fissioned in a chain reaction,
powerful bombs could be created. Szilard recruited two other Hungarian
physicists, Eugene Wigner and Edward Teller. Together these three men
became convinced that not only was the development of a nuclear weapon
possible, but that the German government was already doing research on such
a weapon.
As a result of
this, they decided that President Franklin Roosevelt needed to be aware of
the danger, and the United States must begin its own atomic research
project. In order for this to happen the men needed a trustworthy name that
even the President knew and respected. The man they decided on was Albert
Einstein. Szilard was an old friend of Einstein’s and found out he was
spending the summer on Long Island. So Szilard made an appointment to meet
with him on Sunday, July 16, 1939. As soon as Szilard explained the idea of
how a chain reaction might be created, Einstein was very intrigued. He
enjoyed the idea so much that he immediately agreed to do anything he could
to bring this idea to the attention of the government.
Einstein wrote a
letter to the President regarding the possibilities and dangers of an atomic
weapon. Still, it was not so easy to get an appointment with President
Roosevelt in 1939. Finally in October the President learned of the letter
and the idea it held. The President stated, “This requires action.” A small
committee was set up called the Advisory Committee on Uranium, which
consisted of the head of the Bureau of Standards and representatives of the
army.[3]
The three
Hungarian scientists went to Washington to discuss the situation, but the
military representatives were not impressed by a group of foreign
scientists. They were not convinced that an atomic bomb could even be
created at all, and that it would not make very much of a difference in
war. In the end they agreed to a modest budget to fund further research
into nuclear energy.
Szilard asked for
$6,000 to construct a graphite-uranium system for producing a nuclear chain
reaction. After some arguing the committee finally agreed and the money
slowly arrived. The uranium board was in no hurry because it did not feel
the urgency that the physicists did. The countries of the scientists were
overrun by the Nazis, but the United States was not at war. The possibility
of entering the war was emerging yet the attitude in America was still very
strong against getting involved. The committee still did not really
understand the science behind a nuclear weapon. In their opinion there
seemed to be no reason to rush this program and waste money to develop a
weapon that might not be needed or even work. Then some events occurred
that changed that thought.
Hitler was
sweeping across Europe dominating anything that came in his path. The
possibility that Hitler might soon have access to the most powerful weapon
in the world was very frightening. Then the attacks on Pearl Harbor
happened. Even before the U.S. entry into the war, the pace of research had
increased. In November 1940 the government gave $40,000 to construct a
system suggested by Szilard but designed be Enrico Fermi, an Italian
physicist. The system was based on the use of uranium and graphite.
Work began at
Columbia University but was soon shifted to the University of Chicago. The
University’s Stagg Field, is where construction took place to build the
atomic pile for the experiment. This was conducted in a major city area,
but Fermi was convinced that the reaction could be controlled and posed no
danger, except to those conducting the experiment. The experiment took
place on December 2, 1942. Long control rods, plated with the element
cadmium were set up so they could be inserted into holes in the graphite
bricks and withdrawn when required. The graphite would slow down the
neutrons emitted by the uranium and the cadmium would absorb them. As the
control rods were withdrawn, however, fewer of the neutrons from the uranium
would be absorbed, resulting in greater fission, meaning more atoms
splitting.[4]
The basic principle of a self-created chain reaction had been demonstrated,
after that it was all engineering.
The army had been
involved since June 1942, and by fall the secretary of war realized that
someone was going to have to be in charge. The man that was chosen was
Colonel Leslie Groves. This was not an assignment Colonel Groves wanted, he
wanted to be out fighting the fight with his men. Groves had been in charge
of all military construction and was completing his biggest and most visible
job, the Pentagon. As deputy chief of construction for the entire U.S.
Army, Groves had heard something about the Manhattan Project, but just like
everybody else, he doubted that it would be decisive in winning the war.
While building the Pentagon, he spent more in a week than the entire budget
for the project. Soon thereafter, he became General Groves and was
described as being a tough guy.
Groves did not
care for people who were not like him and more liberal, which is how most of
the scientists working on this project were. He had a tendency to treat
Nobel Prize winners like they were in the army. He did not really
understand the science behind this experiment and did not act as if he did.
So he needed someone to supervise the scientific side of it. He had some
people in mind, but none of them were available. Finally Groves found
someone, Julius Robert Oppenheimer, a 38-year-old physicist who was already
working on the bomb.
The distinction
between Groves and Oppenheimer was obvious, starting with appearance.
Groves was tall and heavier and Oppenheimer was taller and thin, only
weighing in at 135 pounds, by the time he finished his work on the bomb he
was at 113 pounds. Groves did not smoke, rarely drank and disapproved of
both. Oppenheimer was the complete opposite, smoking five packs a day and
had a love of martinis. Even their backgrounds were opposites. Groves was
and army “brat,” who was the straight-laced son of a Presbyterian chaplain.
Oppenheimer came from a wealthy but nonobservant Jewish family. He was
educated at New York City’s Ethical Culture School and some of the best
universities in America as well as Europe. Groves was not a bigot, but had
a gut level distrust of Jews, particularly nonreligious Jews like
Oppenheimer. He did not think they had strong moral values.[5]
Although they had
a lot of differences they were both extremely egotistical. Oppenheimer was
an absolute genius; everyone acknowledged that even though he had not won
the Noble Prize. He was a theoretical physicist rather than a practical
experimentalist. Then there was politics. General Groves completely and
utterly hated the Nazis, but he did not think much more highly of
Communists. Oppenheimer never had any interests in politics until the
devastation of the Great Depression and the rise of Hitler. These two
cataclysmic events changed him. He became a passionate left-winger. He
contributed too many left-wing causes, and spoke at meetings. He was never
a Communist, however his brother, sister-in-law, former fiancée, and wife
all had been. So were many of his closest friends.
Instead of being
put in jail for the duration of the war, he was being offered what was
probably the most security sensitive position in the country, which he
quickly jumped at. When General Groves appointed him as the project’s
scientific director, almost everyone was astonished. Groves saw something
in Oppenheimer that overcame all the possible objections, he saw that
Oppenheimer desperately wanted the job, that he had the utmost confidence in
the project, and that he would do anything he possibly could in order for
the project to succeed. Unlike some of the Manhattan Project scientists
Oppenheimer always treated General Groves with respect. He would explain
the scientific principles to Groves more clearly than anyone else had, and
if he still did not understand, Oppenheimer would explain them again.
There was one
idea of Oppenheimer that Groves liked very much. In 1942 the scientists of
the Manhattan Project were scattered all over the map, working out of
different laboratories, some at Chicago others at Colombia, and the rest at
other universities. Morale was low, because communication was so
difficult. Security was a nightmare for Groves with everyone being so
spread out. Oppenheimer presented the thought of a unified separate
laboratory to focus solely on the weapon itself. The laboratory could be
built in some isolated place, which would help maintain security, but still
allow the scientists to talk freely with on another.
General Groves
was pleased because he had been thinking along the same lines. He thought
most scientists talked too much, but at least if they were all in one place,
surrounded by barbed wire, they could be watched. At one point, Groves
suggested that the scientists could be drafted, wear uniforms, and become
subject to military discipline, Oppenheimer agreed. He even reported to San
Francisco’s Presidio for his army physical.[6]
Other scientists were not as willing to start wearing uniforms and
saluting. Some threatened to quit the project, and the idea of drafting the
scientists into the army was tossed.
Oppenheimer used
his charm to cajole some of the best scientific talent in the country to
join in the search for this weapon. The next big task was to find a
location for his laboratory, called “Site Y.” He already had a place picked
out in his mind, but remained quiet. This site had to have good
transportation, a sufficient supply of water, a local labor force, and a
moderate climate for year-round construction and outdoor experiments.[7]
It also had to be at least two hundred miles from any international
boundary, but west of the Mississippi.
A number of sites
in the Southwest were explored. None of which Oppenheimer was very fond
of. At one point he made a suggestion of going back to Albuquerque through
the town of Los Alamos. He knew this area very well and owned a small ranch
about fifty miles away. This had been the spot where Oppenheimer had
already picked out in his mind. They arrived at the Los Alamos Ranch
School, which housed sons of wealthy families of the East. Groves saw that
it could be easily fenced and liked it right off the bat. The area around
it was full of beautiful views of the land, which would be a lure for the
scientists. It was a perfect setting to develop this ultimate weapon.
General Groves
called Washington that night to begin purchasing the land. The school was
more than happy to sell out, and the deal was complete within the week. The
next month thousands of construction workers moved in and began working. At
that point Oppenheimer was traveling around the country meeting with the
best scientists and trying to get them to sign up for the project by telling
them that they would be working in the mountains of New Mexico, an area that
was absolutely breath-taking, and how the work they would be doing would end
the war.[8]
His tactics worked well in that he got some of the best to agree, including
Enrico Fermi.
Los Alamos
officially opened on April 15, 1943, with about fifty scientists there.
Groves greeted each of them with a handshake and a lecture about how if they
failed he was going to have to go to Congress and justify wasting all of the
money.[9]
The Manhattan Project had begun. As these scientists were working hard to
quickly develop these nuclear weapons, the United States was deep into World
War II.
America had
declared war on Japan, December 8, 1941, the day following the malicious
attacks on Pearl Harbor. Soon thereafter, Germany and Italy declared war on
the U.S. By 1942, American troops were fighting in different areas of the
world. Just like the scientists on the home front, they were hard at work
battling overseas. Not only were they trying to defeat Hitler and the Axis
power, America had a personal vendetta with Japan.
Japan had almost fully conquered Southeast Asia with minimal losses by the
end of April 1942,
chasing the British
and Chinese forces out of Burma, and occupying the country, along
with taking large numbers of prisoners. They further
bombed the Allied
naval base at Darwin, Australia. The only real success against
Japan was a psychological strike from a
bombing raid on Tokyo,
Japan’s capital, in April. Germany was able to regain the initiative as
well. Taking advantage of American inexperience with submarine warfare, the
German Navy
sunk significant
resources near the Atlantic coast. This lasted until about
August.
In early May, Japan initiated operations to
capture Port Moresby,
and sever the line of communications between the United States and
Australia. The Allies, however,
intercepted, and
turned back Japanese naval forces, preventing the invasion.
Japan's next plan, motivated by the earlier bombing on Tokyo, was to seize
the
Midway Islands.
America was not equal in strength to the Japanese, but they relied on the
support of land-based planes from Midway and Honolulu. The fighting started
June 4, 1942. Japanese planes left their carriers and hit the island
target. American planes retaliated by seeking out the invasion force. For
four days, heart-wrenching fighting raged on. A group of American torpedo
bombers kept their attack going until they had all been shot down.
The Americans lost one carrier, the Yorktown, one destroyer, and more than
one hundred planes.[10]
It was a small price to pay to defeat the Japanese Navy, who had forced a
battle with a strong advantage. Although the Japanese had the advantage the
Americans defeated them. Instead of threatening Hawaii and the United
States mainland, Japan was on the defense for the first time. From that
moment on, America began to gather force, and moved persistently towards the
islands of Japan. The Battle of Midway was one of World War II’s most
critical battles. The tides had been turned from then on out. Everything
before Midway was successful for the Japanese, but everything following that
was a failure.
In early June, Japan put their operations into action, but the Americans had
already cracked the
Japanese naval codes
in late May. They were fully aware of the Japanese plans and used this
knowledge to
achieve a decisive
victory over the
Imperial Japanese
Navy. The Americans planned their next
move against Japan’s positions in the southern
Solomon Islands,
primarily against the island of
Guadalcanal.
Both plans started in July, but by mid-September
the battle for
Guadalcanal took priority for the Japanese, and troops in New
Guinea were ordered to withdraw to the
northern part of the
island. Guadalcanal soon became a focal point for both sides,
with heavy commitments of troops, and ships in a battle, that was an attempt
to wear down the enemy by constant fighting. By the start of 1943, the
Japanese were defeated on the island and
withdrew their troops.
Back in the United States, in July 1943, a physicist named Seth
Neddermeyer created the theory of implosion. He proposed that the plutonium
should be surrounded by a layer of explosives. The scientists continued
working, but in early 1944 the difficulties in getting enough quantities of
fissionable material increased. General Groves had taken a big risk by
building a secret factory in Oak Ridge, Tennessee. The factory was only
producing tiny amounts of pure uranium 235. Oppenheimer was told he could
count on enough uranium for only one bomb by the summer of 1945. Another
factory was created in Hanford, Washington, this one produced plutonium
239. It was estimated that this plant would produce enough plutonium for
more than one bomb by 1945.
The two types of
nuclear weapons being developed were the uranium bomb and the plutonium
bomb. The scientists knew the uranium bomb would work without being tested
prior to being dropped. However, with the plutonium being newer and more
complicated, they knew it absolutely had to bed tested before usage.
In the battle for air superiority, the Americans emerged victorious, in part
because the marines kept the ground from attack. The Japanese bombed the
Lunga Point perimeter as often and furiously as they could, usually
coordinating air attacks with other operations, but never closely enough.
The timing of the air attacks became predictable. The marines even ate by
the Japanese air attack clock. They would get two meals a day, not because
a shortage of food, but of the lunchtime bombings.[11]
Skipping the meals and the stress created major fatigue on the troops. The
main question was who would control the night and the surface waters around
Guadalcanal. Up until November 15, it was the Imperial Japanese Navy.
Beginning in 1944, the Japanese introduced a new defense mechanism. The
Americans called them Kamikazes. They followed several critical and
strategic defeats for Japan. Kamikazes were
suicide attacks
by
military aviators,
against the
Allied
ships, in the closing stages of the
Pacific campaigns
of
World War II.
Their main goal was to destroy as many
warships
as possible. Kamikaze pilots would attempt to intentionally crash their
aircraft, often loaded with
explosives,
bombs,
torpedoes
and full
fuel tanks,
into Allied ships. The aircraft's normal role was converted to a manned
missile, in a desperate attempt to increase the accuracy over a normal bomb.
The goal of crippling as many Allied warships as possible was considered
critical enough to warrant the cost of a trained aviator and his aircraft.[12]
In May 1944, while the soldiers battled on, the scientists as well as
the military started searching for place to test the bomb. The location had
to be isolated from any populated area and close enough to Los Alamos to
allow easy movement of the equipment. After finding a spot in an area
called the Jornada del Muerto, construction started in November.
The important Japanese base of
Saipan fell to the
Allied forces on
July 15,
1944. Its
capture provided bases, which enabled U.S. air forces, to strike the
Japanese Home Islands. After the fall of Saipan, the Japanese predicted that
the Allies would try to capture the
Philippines.
In August 1944, it was announced by a news agency that a flight instructor
was training pilots in
Taiwan for
suicide missions. Kamikazes were the most common and best-known form of
Japanese suicide attack during World War II.
In December 1944, General Groves traveled to Washington D.C. and met
with President Roosevelt. They had a meeting discussing the project.
Groves told him that by the summer of 1945, the U-235 will be ready, and
does not need to be tested. He also said that they anticipated a trial of
the plutonium bomb around the same time. The pressure at Los Alamos was
very heavy in 1945. Soon though, Niels Bohr arrived, and participated in
many discussions, offering solutions to some of the technical problems that
needed to be solved. His main contribution was more psychological, than
scientific. In April, the Oak Ridge plant produced enough uranium 235 for a
single bomb. It was then shipped off to Los Alamos, where Rudolf Peierls
built the bomb by hand.[13]
The battle of Iwo Jima was one of the fiercest fights of the war. The
Japanese Army
positions on the island were heavily equipped, with huge
bunkers,
hidden
artillery,
and eleven miles of tunnels. The battle was the first American attack on
the Japanese
Home Islands,
where the soldiers harshly defended their land. Before the Marines stepped
foot on the island, American naval crafts used nearly everything available
to shell the island. Although the bombing was consistent, it did not
discourage the Japanese defenses, since most of the Japanese were hidden and
protected from the shelling.
Many were sheltered by Mount Suribachi itself. The first wave of Marines
was not hit by Japanese fire right away. It was the plan of the Japanese to
hold fire until the beach was full of Marines, and equipment. Many of them,
who landed on the beach in the first wave, figured that the naval firing of
the island had killed all of the Japanese troops that were expected to be
defending it. Marine patrols began to advance inland in search of the
Japanese. Most of the hidden bunkers and firing locations suddenly lit up,
and the Marines took hit after hit, as tons of men were shot down by the
machine guns.
The Marines faced heavy fire from
Mount Suribachi
at the south of the island. It was extremely difficult for the Marines to
advance, because of the inhospitable terrain, which consisted of volcanic
ash. This ash allowed for neither, a secure footing nor, the construction of
defensive foxholes to protect the Marines from fire. In the days after the
landings, the Marines expected a
banzai attack
during the night. This had been the standard Japanese final defense strategy
in previous battles against enemy ground forces in the Pacific.
The fighting was extremely fierce. The Americans' advance was stalled by
numerous defensive situations. They were ambushed by Japanese troops that
occasionally sprung out of the tunnels. The Marines learned that firearms
were relatively ineffective against the Japanese defenders, and instead used
flamethrowers,
and
grenades
to flush out Japanese troops in the tunnels. With the landing area secure,
more troops, and heavy equipment came ashore and the invasion proceeded
north to capture the airfields, and the remainder of the island. Most
Japanese soldiers fought to the death.
On March 18, 1945, the Battle of Okinawa began. This was the largest battle
in the
Pacific
during
World War II.
The battle had one of the highest casualties. The biggest reason for the
battle was to gain a major island close to the main
Japanese islands.
The Allies were beginning to surround Japan, and Okinawa would serve as a
base for the planned invasion of the mainland islands.
Japanese staff officers on Okinawa felt that their headquarters had
abandoned them, and that they would be overwhelmed, and destroyed by the
Americans. The Japanese had used
kamikaze
tactics, but for the first time, they became a major part of their defense.
Between the American landing on
Easter
Sunday, and
May 25,
seven major kamikaze attacks were attempted, involving more than fifteen
hundred planes. The U.S. Navy sustained greater casualties in this
operation, than in any other battle of the war. While no major Allied
warship was lost, several fleet carriers were severely
damaged. General Buckner decided to proceed immediately
with the second part of his plan, which was to attack, and capture northern
Okinawa. The land was very mountainous, and wooded, with the Japanese
defenses concentrated on a twisted mass of rocky ridges, and narrow valleys.
There was heavy fighting and the Americans were at a disadvantage. The
Japanese knew these lands, and all the hiding spots. The Americans were
going into this battle blind, not knowing anything about the land. In
addition to all the fighting, they encountered suicide bombers, and even
Japanese women armed with spears. The island fell on
June 23,
1945,
though some Japanese continued fighting.
During the Battle of Okinawa, a tragic event occurred in the United States
on April 12, 1945, President Roosevelt had died. In his fight to defeat the
Axis power, he unfortunately did not get to see the end. Even though he
passed, the war still went on, and so did the Manhattan Project.
Vice-President Harry Truman became President, and on April 25, was visited
by Henry Stimpson, the Secretary of War. This meeting is where Truman
learned about the atomic bombs for the first time.
Also in April, the Japanese government had prepared a war policy
called Ketsugo. These plans would prepare the Japanese people
psychologically to die as a nation, defending their homeland. Even children,
including girls, would be trained to use improvised lethal weapons, and
encouraged to sacrifice themselves by killing an American invader. In order
to train the children to kill, soldiers attended schools on how to use
weapons, such as bamboo spears.
The scattering of
these military resources across Japan, and their careful disguise, would
provide the Americans with no opportunity to destroy them from the air. The
Ketsugo policy placed heavy dependence on suicide attacks on American
troops, and their warships. For this reason, several thousand Japanese
aircrafts would be modified for suicide attacks. Other methods of suicide
attacks, included dynamite-filled crash boats, guided human torpedoes,
guided human rocket bombs, and specially trained ground suicide units
carrying explosives.
In addition to
all of these, the invading Americans would have to face a civilian
population drilled in guerilla war tactics, who would rather die than be
captured by an American. The Americans had every reason to be deeply
concerned when they learned about Japanese plans to defend the home islands
by massive suicide attacks. The Kamikaze suicide attacks on Allied ships at
Okinawa had alone produced a horrendous amount of casualties.
In May 1945, the
war in Europe ended with the surrender of Germany, and the death of Hitler.
America was very happy, but they still had a battle to face in the Pacific.
Many of the men who battled over in Europe were shipped over to the
Pacific. America also found out that the Germans did not have an atomic
bomb or anything close to it. Nevertheless the race to finish it was still
going on. After the defeat of Germany, the Imperial Army started pulling
back to get ready for the American invasion.
The goal at the
beginning of the Manhattan Project was to beat Hitler. With the fall of the
Third Reich and the death of Hitler, nobody at Los Alamos or Washington
considered stopping. There was still the war in Asia, where it was clear
that the Japanese were defeated, but were not willing to give up until the
last man was killed. Stalin, Churchill, and Truman agreed to meet in
Potsdam on July 15, to discuss Europe and the war in the Pacific. General
Groves set the target date for the test to be on July 16, so Truman could
have the knowledge of having an atomic weapon in his hands. The meeting was
held off until July 17.
The plutonium did
not arrive until May 31 from Hanford. Before this, nobody had ever seen the
material before. Up to that point it was all theory. The bomb existed only
in notes and calculations. The plutonium core was taken to Trinity on July
12. The next day the core was driven to the base of the one hundred foot
tower, built to drop the bomb. On July 15, lots of observers began to
arrive. They were going to watch the test about twenty miles away. General
Groves was concerned about possible saboteurs. He thought the Japanese
might launch a parachute assault, and he ordered a team to guard the tower
before the scheduled test.[14]
The testing was
ready to go, everyone got into their designated positions. The countdown
began, a one-minute warning rocket and siren went off. At 5:29 A.M. on July
16, 1945, the bomb was dropped, and the sky lit up. The bomb had worked,
and for the first time in history, nuclear weapons had been created. On
July 26, the Potsdam Declaration was created. This outlined
the terms of surrender for
Japan as
agreed upon at the
Potsdam Conference.
The agreement stated that if Japan did not surrender, it would face prompt
and utter destruction to the Japanese, and its people.
After the success at Trinity, bombing raids occurred over Japan. As
the number of American lives soared, and Japan showed signs of admitting
defeat, the Americans finally decided strike, with the bombing raids. These
raids were devastating to the cities, because houses were made of wood and
rice paper, so the fire would spread rapidly, destroying homes, and killing
people. The raids soon stopped. However, instead of persuading Japan
to surrender, the Japanese government was able to use the air raids to
create more hatred towards the Americans, and strengthen the spirit of the
Japanese people to fight to the death as a nation.[15]
When the Potsdam Declaration was made, Truman
sent a warning out to Japan, that if they did not surrender unconditionally,
they would face utter destruction. The Japanese rejected the Declaration,
and so the plan to drop an atomic bomb was constructed. On August 6, 1945,
the first atomic bomb was released over the city of Hiroshima. The bomb
destroyed the entire city, and killed massive amounts of people. The
Japanese still did not surrender, so three days later, the second bomb was
dropped over the city of Nagasaki, again destroying the entire city and
people. On August 15, 1945, the emperor of Japan surrendered.
Throughout the duration of the war, the Japanese were known for their
malicious and brutal acts, like the deadly program of testing out
experiments to help develop biological-warfare ability, and making thousands
of non-Japanese women provide sexual services for the soldiers, plus many
other things. Cannibalism was something the Japanese not only did to other
countries, but to each other. In most cases, Japanese soldiers were the
victims in places like New Guinea towards the end of the war, when their
supplies got cut off. There were also incidents when Allied soldiers and
the local citizens would fall victim. Japanese soldiers referred to the
Allies as “white pigs” and the locals as “black pigs.”[16]
The condition of a persons scalp indicated that Japanese soldiers tried to
remove the brains of the victims, but were interrupted before they could
finish. A majority of times, the Japanese soldiers did not have time to
dispose of the disfigured body or cooked remains.
The soldiers
would remove the bodies of Allied soldiers from an area where fierce combat
was taking place, and brought them to a safer spot to prevent the Allies
from recovering the bodies. It was not just on the Allied soldiers that the
Japanese acted with cannibalism, but also on Chinese and Indian Muslims who
were prisoners of war. Some more carnage occurred with Unit 731. This was
the secret biological warfare unit which part of its research was
experimented on humans. During World War II, the Japanese used biological
weapons against the Chinese. They sprayed cholera, typhoid, plague, and
dysentery pathogens. This was done in retaliation after the first United
States air raids on Tokyo and Nagoya. The aircrafts landed on airfields
located in China, this was seen as them collaborating with the Allies.[17]
Unit 731 used
tons of Chinese people for experiments, many of whom had retaliated against
the Japanese. They also performed frostbite experiments on prisoners of
war. They would be tied up outside, in weather that some nights would reach
below zero, along with that, parts of their bodies would be sprayed with
salt water in order to induce frostbite. Their arms would be hit with
hammers, in order to see if they were frostbitten. Following this, they
would be immersed in hot water of ranging temperatures, in order to
determine how recovery from frostbite could best be facilitated.[18]
Other victims would undergo surgeries and amputations
without anesthesia. The anesthesia would not be used because they considered
it to affect the results. In some victims, animal blood would be injected
into their bodies.
Not only did the
Japanese treat other countries with such disrespect, but they were even
worse with American soldiers. Japan prides itself on being respectful to
the dead, but the Japanese were like vultures when it came to the dead
Allied soldiers. They would dismantle them, even going so far as to cutting
off their penis' and sticking it in the dead soldiers mouth. They had no
disregard for any human kind other than themselves, and the emperor.
The dropping of
the atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagaski, was needed to stop the Japanese,
and save half a million American lives. The Japanese were not willing to
surrender unconditionally, and were ready to fight to the very end. After
the bloody and devastating Battles of Iwo Jima, and Okinawa, President
Truman did not want to go into another battle, and lose hundreds of
thousands of American lives. To the Japanese, surrender was not an option,
they viewed it as disgraceful. With that in mind, they were willing to keep
on battling until every last citizen was dead. Although the casualties from
the two bombs were large, they do not compare to the amount of Japanese who
would have died if the whole population of Japan kept fighting the
war. America was not involved in
World War II, until the Japanese slyly attacked Pearl Harbor, without any
mercy. They starved, tortured, and killed American prisoners of war, along
with innocent people from different countries. To save many more young men
from being killed and tormented, and many young women from being raped, the
bomb was dropped. The Japanese were a poison killing the world, a poison
that needed to be stopped, by any means necessary.
Notes
[1]
J. Samuel Walker, prompt & utter
destruction: Truman and the Use of Atomic Bombs Against Japan (North
Carolina: The University of North Carolina Press, 2004), 109.
[2]
Ronald Takaki, Hiroshima: Why America Dropped the Atomic Bomb
(New York: Little, Brown and Company, 1995), 113.
[3]Daniel
Cohen, The Manhattan Project (Connecticut: The Millbrook Press,
1999),19-20.
[10]
Joanna Bourke, The Second World War (United Kingdom: Oxford
University Press, 2001), 92.
[11]
Williamson Murray and Allan R. Millett, A War to be Won: Fighting the
Second World W r (Massachusetts: The Belknap of Harvard, 2000),
213.
[16]
Yuki Tanaka, Hidden Horrors (Colorado: Westview Press, 1996),
114.
[18]
Tanaka, 139.
Bibliography
Bourke, Joanna, The Second World War. Oxford: Oxford University
Press, 2001.
Bradley, James, Flags of Our Fathers. New York: Bantam Books,
2001.
Cohen, Daniel, The Manhattan Project. Connecticut: The Millbrook
Press, 1999.
Gonzales, Dorren, The Manhattan Project and The Atomic Bomb: In
American History. Berkeley Heights: Enslow Publishers, Inc., 2000.
Murray, Williamson, Millett, Allan, R. A War to Be Won.
Cambridge: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 2000.
Takaki, Ronald, Hiroshima: Why America Dropped the Atomic Bomb.
New York: Little, Brown and Company, 1995.
Walker, J. Samuel, prompt & utter destruction: Truman and the Use of
Atomic Bombs Against Japan. Chapel Hill: The University of North
Carolina Press, 2004.
|